On an ordinary day in 1130, Zhu Xi was born
in Youxi county, Fujian Province.
In ancient China, it is
common for the ancestry of
great people to be shrouded in mystery.
For example,
there are still many uncertainties regarding
Confucius' family.
However,
Zhu Xi's family is unambiguous.

In the book "Textual Research of Zhu Xi's Achievements"
written by Gao Yinling, Zhu Xi's ancestors migrated from
Shandong
to Fujian.
According to Mr Gao’s
research,
Zhu Xi's early ancestors
from the Spring and Autumn period
lived
in
a small country named "Zhu",
which
is
located between big countries such
as “Qi” and “Lu” at the time.
Their
descendents then
traveled and lived in Shandong,
Jiangsu,
Anhui Province and finally settled down in Fujian province when
Zhu Xi was born.
Although there is no
serious comparison
between Zhu Xi and Confucius,
there is little
doubt that
besides Confucious and Meng Zi,
Zhu Xi
left
the third biggest impact on Chinese social thinking. Zhu Xi
was thought to be the greatest philosopher throughout Song,
Yuan, Ming, Qing dynasty.
The article below
is a brief introduction
to
Zhu Xi and his philosophical thoughts.
Facing
hills and Reading books
Zhu Xi's father, Zhu Song, was born
to a landlord family in Jiangxi
Province. However, his family’s
circumstances were already in decline when he was born.
Even when he later achieved the rank of lieutenant, and
was deployed to
You Xi county,
Nanjian
State and
Fujian
Province, he was still
disregarded by his colleagues.
Fortunately, Nanjian district was the hometown of Yang Shi,
who was the student of another great Confucian,
Cheng Hao. Yang
Shi
spent all of his time teaching in his hometown
in his
old age, which
turned the
Nanjian district
into
a center of
Neo-Confucian thinking led by
Cheng. Zhu Song had
once
been taught by Luo Congyan, who was a student of Yang
Shi. He was
thus keen on Neo-Confucianism and
remained in
close contact with local moralists. This home environment
surely had a profound impact on Zhu Xi. Though Zhu
Song
he
preferred
Zhu Xi to be a soldier
rather
than a Confucian,
the
Zhu family was
famous for Confucianism and
they eventually
would
trained
Zhu Xi
to
become a Confucian.
Even as a child, Zhu Xi
was very clever. When he was 4 years
old, his father Zhu
Song pointed to the sky,
and said "this is the
Heavens".
Zhu
Song was surprised when
Zhu Xi asked, "What is
in
Heaven?".
At that time, moralists were very interested in whether the
Heaven is bounded and in his
autobiography,
Zhu Xi had
once
fallen
ill thinking about the question.
By
the age of 8, Zhu Xi
could read Classic of Filial Piety,
and one day wrote "If I
don’t honour my parents, I would rather die" to encourage himself.

Zhu
Xi
wrote an antithetical couplet and engraved it on the wall as
his motto in his old age. It said
that he would abide his father and master's word. Throughout
his life, he always
abided
by the motto. Zhu
Xi's father, Zhu
Song, died when Zhu Xi
was at the young age of 14.
Zhu
Xi
followed his father's will
and
moved to Liu Ziyu's home,
Chong An county, with his mother. He began learning from Hu Xian, Liu
Mianzhi, Liu Zihui and under their influence,
became
deeply interested in
Cheng’s
Neo-Confucianism and Buddhist idealism. In 1153,
Zhu Xi met moralists Li Dong on the way to
Tongan county, and this meeting made
a big difference on Zhu Xi's world view. Li Dong advised Zhu
Xi to give up Buddhism, but Zhu Xi refused.
However,
when
Zhu Xi met Li Dong
five years later, he took greater interest in Li’s
sayings, perhaps because of his experience as chief of
records in Chong An.
Based on the quotation of Xie Liangzuo,
who was another follower of Cheng Yi, Zhu Xi started to
collect books written by moralists in Northern Song Dynasty.
In
1160, Zhu Xi decided to learn from Li Dong.
However,
Zhu Xi still remained
rooted in
Buddhist
teachings and Li Dong asked him to
read Classical Confucianism. After reading
numerous
Confucianism books, Zhu Xi
began to understand Li Dong’s words. He agreed with
Confucianism and saw that there were
shortcomings in
Buddhism.
Zhu Xi
then
began to
create his own idealist system
based
on Confucianism.
However, instead of
abandoning Buddhism completely he
integrated
it
into his idealist system. In
a letter to Luo
Bo, Li Dong happily boasted that Zhu
Xi studied very hard, which was rare in their party. He
talked with him that day and felt pleased.
As history
later showed,
Li Dong was right about
his student.
Zhu Xi not only
inherited Li Dong's theory, but also
greatly
surpassed him.
In
the book "Zhu Xi's Historical World" written by Yu Yingshi,
it
is
said that Zhu Xi's
historical world
started forming from this point forth.
Due to Zhu Xi’s political
career and the common misunderstandings about his political
affiliations, it's
necessary to give a brief account on how
Zhu Xi's
historical world began.
First,
the
political culture of
the
Song dynasty
traces back to the beginning
of the “Three Generations”, which was during a period before
the
Han and Tang Dynasties.
The three generations are
the
Xia, Shang and Zhou dynasty. Most Confucians in Song dynasty
looked down on Han and Tang, but highly praised the three
generations. Hence,
the political reform in Xining was
spurred by this view.
Scholars eventually
painted
"The three
generations"
and the Han and Tang
dynasties as opposing political
concepts, which
displeased
Chen
Liang and sparked his famous debate
with
Zhu Xi
regarding the tyranny of the king.
Second, the political status of
scholars
was greatly enhanced in Song dynasty for
many reasons.
For
example, Song's policy
to
desist from military activities and encourage culture and education; the first emperor's testament
to refrain from
killing
scholars etc. These have been
explicitly stated in Yu Yingshi's book.
It’s worth noting that the ideas of serving society, and the
phenomenon of
scholars joining the
Emperor’s
national government had been
universally accepted. These ideas never existed
before the Song dynasty.
The
idea
of “making society one’s personal responsibility”
is still praised
nowadays and this can actually
be traced back to the time of Confucius,
which was also the time
when the ancient Chinese
Scholar class
was formed.
Since then,
scholars
started to
view benevolence as every
individual’s responsibility and became advocates of ethics.
However, there is
a distinction between
benevolence
and serving society.
The former mainly focuses on the
bearer of
a
value system, while the latter reflects
an
entitlement to participate
directly in political and social affairs, which can be
widely seen throughout the Song dynasty. The
idea
of
serving society
spurred the movement for
intellectuals
to
join
the emperor
in national governance.
It was during this historical period that
Zhu Xi
began his
political career and
he aspired to govern
the
nation
in a way similar to the
Xia, Shang and
Zhou dynasties.
(abbreviated to Three Dynasties’
Governance). However, although Zhu Xi
believed that
the way of Three Dynasties’ Governance
could not be applied on a national scale,
he also thought it would be
applicable on a localized scale.
As the representative of
scholars then,
he showed
a
great sense of social responsibility by
designing a new system to re-establish
the traditional Confucian order. He made great efforts to
apply his
model of
governance to a local area and
this resulted in
the
emergence and enforcement of local institutions, such as the
Free Estate’s Family(义庄) and Local treaties(乡约).
In
1167 AD, when Zhu Xi
took
up office in
Fujian,
the
Chong
An district
was struck by floods and
Zhu Xi
travelled
round Chong
An and
analyze the situation.
He
suggested
setting up social
warehouse
and Wufuli to solve food supply problem. In 1190,
Zhu Xi
was
posted to
Zhang Zhou, where land
annexation was very
rampant.
Landlords
were buying
peasants' land but
leaving the
tax liability
with the peasants.
Farmers were
also
cruelly
exploited.
To solve this problem,
Zhu Xi came up with “boundary survey”, and proposed that
tax
liability follows land, which
damaged the interests of the big landlords.
However, the
landlords
fought
strongly against
his policy and
refused to
cooperate with him,
causing the implementation of
these ideas
to
fail. Zhu Xi was so angry that he resigned
in
protest.

Deny
self and return to propriety
Zhu
Xi’s philosophy extended to
five
main
areas. These were the
Liqi theory, Movement and stillness opinion, the theory of
Extending Knowledge by Investigating Things, theory of
"Heart-Nature" and the Aesthetic Thought.
The
mention of Zhu Xi’s philosophy used to invoke thoughts of
“Upholding justice and
annihilating desire” and “Starving to death over forfeiting loyalty”. It would also
invoke
the image of feudalism’s
keeper because the
idea
of “upholding justice
and annihilating desire”
was widely thought to be inhuman
due to the use of
feudal moral principles to restrict people’s desire.
Hence, this view was attacked by
the critic,
Tang Zhongyou, as soon as it was
presented and even led
to the case of Yan Rui.
Furthermore, the
celebrated scholar, Lu Xun,
also made some
sarcastic
remarks
about Zhu Xi.
However, as
a matter of fact, Zhu Xi’s
idea
to uphold justice and annihilate desire
referred to
undue desire.
What is this
undue desire? For example, a person who is stuffed but still
wishes to
eat bird’s-nest has
undue desire; a
person who already has a wife but still
wishes for
more wives also has
undue desire. Such a view is connected with his theory of
"Heart-Nature".
To
avoid misunderstanding Zhu Xi, it is necessary for us to
put his saying into
its
specific historical context.
Zhu Xi’s
theory of human nature was
actually an
elaboration of the theory of
Zhang Zai and Cheng Yi on “nature and temperament”.
According to his theory,
nature specifically refers to “being”,
which is perfect itself.
Temperament
refers to the mixture of being and temperament, which is not completely good, but
coexists in humans. Neither one is dispensable.
Related to
the nature is the theory of moral mind and human mind. In
Zhu Xi’s opinion, “moral mind”
stems from
the nature principle, which inherently incorporates the
faith
in humanity, justice,
etiquette, wisdom and develops into
a
consciousness of compassion, shamefulness, humility, and the
concept of right and wrong.
On the other hand,
the
“human mind”
stems from
the human instinct, such as hunger for food and thirst to
drink.
Hence, although even sages
cannot do without the human mind, they place an emphasis on
the moral mind rather than the human mind. Zhu Xi thought
that the
moral mind and human
mind
were contradictory, yet
related to each other. He felt that the moral mind
achieves stability through
the
human mind, but
that the
human mind should be
subjected to
the
moral mind.
Hence,
Zhu Xi
reached
his view of
the
nature principle
and the human mind
through the Mind-nature theory. He considered that
the
human mind
is
selfish,
which makes it weak.
In contrast,
the
moral mind
stems
from
nature, which makes it
subtle. Thus,
when
he proposed the
idea
of “Upholding justice and annihilating desire”,
he
was
affirming the normal desires of material life and objecting to the Buddhist view of
completely removing desire. In his saying, Zhu Xi was actually referring to the
undue desire which exceeds the basic human material desire.
The
main reason why Zhu Xi’s theory had evolved into an extreme
point of view was because the rulers of the time had
exploited his saying and driven such extreme thoughts deep
into the people’s hearts. This, unfortunately, sometimes led
to tragedy when his view was misinterpreted to mean
“Keep one’s chastity
rather than
starve to death”.
The sun and moon
are
the eye of the earth,
More and more reading is the way to be a sage
This antithetical couplet,
written by Zhu Xi, on the door of the White Deer
Grotto Academy, seems to indicate his
path
in
life. Although Zhu Xi was mistaken during and after his
lifetime, his articles and thoughts lasted forever.
What mattered more was
his
diligence throughout his lifetime, and his devotion
to building the college.
Today, though the premises
are empty and the conviction of young learners has faded,
the college seems to have surpassed immeasurable time. It
now awaits future generations who may continue the
river of culture
and
the tradition of learning to be a sage.
We have mentioned that Zhu Xi’s life in politics only lasted for seven years, most
of which
was spent on
researches, writing articles and imparting knowledge. According to
relevant history records,
it is
seen
that Zhu Xi often asked for leave. A
part of the reason
might have been due to
personal affairs, such as his mother’s death,
but
the biggest reason
was
because he wanted to devote more time
to his
research and
teaching. In 1162, Zhu Xi was ordered to “Lin An”— the
capital
city
of the time –
to make a proposal to
the emperor. He proposed that the top
priority
for the government
should be
to teach and create
a scheme to assign worthy people.
The
proposal is
known as “Ren Wu
Feng Shi(壬午封事)”, and it contains forward-looking
strategies
similar to
today’s strategy of
rejuvenating the country through science and education. The
difference between these two proposals is that the former
did not attract
the emperor’s attention and
was
thus not implemented at all.
Even in
his
short political career, Zhu Xi
had
been
aware of the importance of education. In 1178, Zhu Xi
received
another opportunity to
enter politics when
he was ordered to
assume the office of “Zhi Nan Kang Jun(知南康军)”。 However, during his
time in office,
he never forgot his mission as a scholar. He
thus
established the White Deer Grotto Academy in the historical
site of Li Bo, poet of Tang dynasty, and formulated
a set of studying norms in the academy.
Below are some excerpts:
“There should be affection between fathers and sons,
affiliation between monarchs and courtiers, distinction
between husbands and wives, order between seniors and
juniors, and trust amongst friends.”
“Study extensively, inquire prudently, reflect carefully,
differentiate things clearly, perform consistently.”
“Speak honestly, behave politely, abstain
from
anger, restrict undue desire, amend
wrongs and
strive to be kind.”
“Act for the common good instead of personal interests, work
according to the moral principle instead of individual
benefit.”
“Treat others as you would like to be treated, seek the
cause in oneself instead of somebody else.”
The
White Deer Grotto Academy is one of the four biggest and
most famous academies in Chinese history.
Its study norms have become the
paragon of other academies with a great influence on the
latter generations.
Besides his contribution to the education, Zhu Xi also
strived to make his theory of
Confucianism the ruling thoughts of the then government.
However, as a new thought, his theory of Confucianism had
little
impact on the contemporary society. Moreover, due to his
upright character, he often offended the powerful ministers,
which led to the disastrous political
consequences.
In 1195, Zhao Ruyu—the central government official who
supported Zhu Xi --
was
forced out by another powerful official, Han Tuozhou, who was favored by the emperor. As
a result, Zhu Xi was
dragged into the conflict
as he had
once
attacked Han Tuozhou.
Hence,
Han Tuozhou radically attacked Zhu Xi’s Confucianism. In
1196,
Ye Zhu—proponents of Han
signed a petition
asking the emperor to
destroy all the books written by the moralists and to bar any
candidate who upheld Cheng Zhu
Confucianism in the imperial examinations
from
being admitted.
To make matters worse, the then
monitoring censor, Shen Jizu, accused Zhu Xi of ten crimes, and
asked
the emperor to
kill him. Zhu Xi’s star pupil Cai Yuanding was also arrested and sent to Dao Province. Cheng Zhu
Confucianism was completely discredited and scolded false
theory by the Song government.
Accordingly, Zhu Xi was also lambasted as the teacher of the
false theory. At that time, Zhu Xi was 69 years old and
was
deteriorating physically.
He lost the support of Emperor Ningzong, and was prohibited
from being
a government official.
In the fall of
that year, Zhu Xi
moved to Wu Fu Li,
Chong An, and finished
his work “Chu Ci Ji Zhu”. During this tough time, he
exchanged letters
with
then famous Ci writer,
Xin Qiji,
and encouraged
each other
using the idea of
“self-denial” and “letting propriety show through one’s
words and actions”. On November 3,
1200, he passed away in his home at the age of 71. According
to historical records, he
had amending his work “Da
Xue Cheng Yi Zhang”
till his death,
once again showing
his enthusiasm to build up his theory of Confucianism.
During
the most depressing
times when Zhu Xi was beaten
by his opponents and his
version of
Confucianism was forbidden by the government,
it is touching to know that he thought fondly of Confucius. He signaled his
with regret that Confucius died in 479 B.C,
and lamented the following words, “it’s
1670 years up to now”.
This clearly show that Zhu Xi
was eerily reminiscent of Confucius and
that he was proud to be a
successor of the Confucian orthodoxy
of Confucius and Meng Zi.
In Chinese culture, when we admire someone, we often
described
the nobility of
his
character
to be
as high as the hills, as long as the
rivers, and of lasting influence. Zhu Xi is such an
intellectual who deserves our respect.
Some
Terminologies:
理
Being
欲
desire
道心
moral mind
人心
human mind
天理
nature principle
人欲
human desire
仁义礼智信Humanity,
Justice, Etiquette, Wisdom and Faith
心性说
mind-nature theory
存天理,灭人欲Uphold
justice , annihilate desire
程朱理学
Cheng-Zhu Confucianism
克己复礼
deny self and return to propriety
内圣外王
internal sage and external king
孔孟道统The
Confucian orthodoxy of Confucius and Menzi
道
Moral
仁
Kernel
义庄
the Free Estate’s Family(Yi-zhuang)
乡约
local treaties